I think you did me a big favor by asking this. I pulled the car out to get the mower out, so I figured I take the pics then. I sat down by the fender, and no holes. I pulled the pentastar off, so I knew the holes were there. I looked inside the fender, and I could see the holes. The only thing I can think of till I talk to my paint guy, is there must have been some pitting on the fender and he did a skim coat. I remember seeing the fender before he primered it, and there was no rust. sure glad I caught this before the car was painted and I was trying to put my new Pentastar on!