The first one is an aftermarket unit and is a different design then the original radio was. The second is the correct design, that is having the thumbwheel type controls, and the prices are usually close to that price but that one is higher then some others I have seen. There is no one that builds the radios as originally designed, so if you want the factory look you will need to spend the big bucks, if you're not concerned about that look and would rather save some money, then the other one will work.